When you begin a renovation project one of the key considerations is whether to renovate or replace the larger structures within the building, in particular, the staircase.
To the general DIYer, it can be hard to assess whether it is worth the time, cost and effort to attempt to repair a staircase, when a complete replacement may actually end up being quicker and cheaper. With this in mind, Staircase specialist Jackson Woodturners spoke to two industry experts to discover when you should renovate, and when it’s time to replace.
Scott Else – Scott Else WoodWorks
Mark Finney – Finneys Wood Finishes
Staircases in period properties often boast original design features that are worth preserving if possible. This is not just for the aesthetic qualities, original features often serve as desirable selling points for resale purposes. According to Scott, things to look out for include:
“I would be looking for original mouldings, the shape of spindles and newel posts etc. and any sign of damage either through wear or rotting. If all is good then it would be worth restoring.”
Sometimes it isn’t just the aesthetics that may need addressing, there may also be also be structural issues, which can obviously present health and safety risks. Knowing when to call in the professionals can make a huge difference to the success (not to mention the cost) of the job, as Mark elaborates:
“If you ever feel out of your depth, or have damaged the wood by incorrect sanding, or by the incorrect application of materials, especially wood stains… STOP. Any remedial work required will become much more expensive to do the more there is to put right and, in some cases, cannot ever be satisfactorily rectified.”
Scott agrees, stressing on the importance of maintaining safety:
“If the structural strength is compromised then definitely call in a professional. For example, if you have broken/rotten treads, risers or strings.”
When making the decision whether to renovate and replace it is always worth gaining professional advice on the extent of the job, that way you can properly assess the extent and cost of the job before making a potentially costly mistake.
